Tired of harsh chemicals in your store-bought eye makeup removers? Discover the magic of creating your own! Making your own makeup remover is not only gentle and effective, but it’s also a fantastic way to pamper your skin with natural goodness.
These DIY recipes focus on simple, nourishing ingredients that melt away stubborn makeup, leaving your delicate eye area feeling clean, soft, and refreshed.
Get ready to ditch the expense and embrace a more natural approach to makeup removal!.
Table of Contents
1. Gentle Eye Makeup Remover with Coconut Oil and Lavender
This soothing eye makeup remover is a dream for your delicate skin, combining the powerful yet gentle makeup-dissolving properties of coconut oil with the calming scent of lavender essential oil.
It effortlessly melts away mascara and eyeliner, leaving your lashes and the skin around your eyes feeling soft and nourished.
Plus, lavender adds a lovely touch that makes your nightly routine feel extra relaxing..
Key Ingredients:
- Distilled Water
- Gentle Tear-Free Soap
- Coconut Oil
- Lavender Essential Oil
Benefits:
- Effortless Makeup Removal
- Nourishes Lashes
- Gentle on Sensitive Skin
- Calming Scent
Pro Tip: For an added lash boost, gently dab a tiny bit of the remover onto your lashes with a Q-tip after wiping makeup away.
Get the Recipe: Gentle Eye Makeup Remover with Coconut Oil and Lavender
2. Soothing Eye Makeup Remover with Witch Hazel, Aloe Vera, and Olive Oil
This refreshing eye makeup remover is a lovely blend that’s light on the skin yet tough on makeup.
It combines the natural astringent properties of witch hazel with the soothing touch of aloe vera gel and the makeup-melting power of olive oil.
This creates a wonderfully balanced formula that cleanses without leaving a greasy feel, making your skin feel calm and clean..
Key Ingredients:
- Olive Oil
- Witch Hazel
- Aloe Vera Gel
- Vitamin E
Benefits:
- Light and Non-Greasy
- Soothing and Calming
- Effective Makeup Removal
- Tones Skin
Pro Tip: Give the bottle a good shake before each use, as the ingredients can naturally separate.
Get the Recipe: Soothing Eye Makeup Remover with Witch Hazel, Aloe Vera, and Olive Oil
3. Lash-Nourishing Eye Makeup Remover with Coconut Oil and Castor Oil
For those looking to boost lash health while removing makeup, this recipe is a winner.
It features the nourishing power of coconut oil, known for its conditioning benefits, combined with castor oil, which is celebrated for promoting lash growth.
A touch of lavender and tea tree oil adds extra benefits, creating a potent yet gentle remover that leaves your eyes clean and your lashes feeling strong..
Key Ingredients:
- Unrefined Coconut Oil
- Castor Oil
- Lavender Essential Oil
- Tea Tree Essential Oil
Benefits:
- Promotes Lash Health
- Deeply Nourishing
- Gentle Cleansing
- Natural Antibacterial Properties
Pro Tip: For a lighter texture, you can whip the ingredients with a hand mixer before transferring them to a jar.
Get the Recipe: Lash-Nourishing Eye Makeup Remover with Coconut Oil and Castor Oil
4. Simple Eye Makeup Remover with Witch Hazel and Almond Oil
This incredibly simple two-ingredient wonder uses the gentle cleansing power of witch hazel combined with the moisturizing benefits of almond oil.
It’s perfect for easily dissolving eye makeup without any fuss.
The light texture feels lovely on the skin, and it’s a great option if you prefer to avoid coconut oil or want a very straightforward, effective remover..
Key Ingredients:
- Witch Hazel Extract
- Olive Oil
- Avocado Oil
- Sweet Almond Oil
- Fractionated Coconut Oil
- Jojoba Oil
Benefits:
- Gentle and Effective
- Moisturizing
- Easy to Make
- Tightens Pores
Pro Tip: Consider using extra virgin olive oil or avocado oil as alternatives if you have them on hand; they work beautifully too.
Get the Recipe: Simple Eye Makeup Remover with Witch Hazel and Almond Oil
5. Nourishing Eye Makeup Remover Wipes with Coconut Oil and Castile Soap
Create your own convenient makeup remover wipes with this easy DIY! Infused with moisturizing fractionated coconut oil, gentle castile soap, and skin-toning witch hazel, these wipes effortlessly lift away makeup.
They’re super quick to make, budget-friendly, and a much kinder alternative to store-bought wipes, leaving your skin feeling soft and cared for..
Key Ingredients:
- Fractionated Coconut Oil
- Witch Hazel
- Unscented Castile Soap
- Aloe Vera Gel
- Essential Oils
Benefits:
- Convenient Wipes
- Alcohol-Free
- Moisturizing
- Gentle on Skin
Pro Tip: For a zero-waste option, use reusable bamboo or cotton pads instead of disposable cotton rounds.
Get the Recipe: Nourishing Eye Makeup Remover Wipes with Coconut Oil and Castile Soap
6. Simple 2-Ingredient Makeup Remover without Coconut Oil
If coconut oil doesn’t agree with your skin, this two-ingredient recipe is a fantastic alternative! It pairs the gentle cleansing and toning of witch hazel with a nourishing oil like jojoba or olive oil.
This simple blend effectively dissolves makeup, including around the eyes, without any harshness, leaving your skin feeling clean and balanced..
Key Ingredients:
- Witch Hazel
- Jojoba Oil
- Sweet Almond Oil
- Avocado Oil
- Apricot Kernel Oil
- Olive Oil
- Fractionated Coconut Oil
Benefits:
- Coconut Oil-Free Option
- Gentle and Effective
- Balances Skin
- Easy to Customize
Pro Tip: Shake well before use, as the oil and witch hazel will naturally separate.
Get the Recipe: Simple 2-Ingredient Makeup Remover without Coconut Oil
7. Effective Eye Makeup Remover with Water, Castile Soap, and Oil
This versatile recipe uses a base of filtered water combined with a touch of gentle castile soap and a nourishing oil like jojoba.
It’s designed to effectively melt away stubborn makeup, including waterproof mascara, without irritating your delicate eye area.
Creating this solution and using it with cotton rounds or a soft cloth makes for a quick and refreshing makeup removal process..
Key Ingredients:
- Filtered Water
- Jojoba Oil
- Castile Soap
- Tea Tree Oil
Benefits:
- Melts Away Makeup
- Chemical-Free
- Reduces Waste
- Cost-Effective
Pro Tip: To keep your homemade wipes fresh, store them in the refrigerator if you don’t add a preservative.
Get the Recipe: Effective Eye Makeup Remover with Water, Castile Soap, and Oil
8. Gentle Eye Makeup Remover with Distilled Water, Gentle Soap, and Oil
This straightforward recipe is a budget-friendly way to create a highly effective eye makeup remover.
By combining distilled water with a mild, tear-free baby soap and your favorite skin-friendly oil (like almond, olive, or coconut), you get a gentle yet powerful formula.
It easily dissolves makeup, leaving your eyes clean and your skin feeling soft, without any of the harsh chemicals found in many commercial products..
Key Ingredients:
- Distilled Water
- Tear-Free Baby Wash
- Almond Oil
- Olive Oil
- Coconut Oil
Benefits:
- Cost-Effective
- Gentle on Eyes
- Effectively Removes Makeup
- Simple Ingredients
Pro Tip: You can make a large batch and transfer some to a smaller squirt bottle for easier application.
Get the Recipe: Gentle Eye Makeup Remover with Distilled Water, Gentle Soap, and Oil
9. Pure Coconut Oil for Effortless Makeup Removal
Sometimes, the simplest solutions are the best! Pure coconut oil is a natural powerhouse for dissolving all kinds of makeup, including stubborn eye makeup.
It glides on smoothly, melting away mascara and liner with ease, while also conditioning your lashes and the delicate skin around your eyes.
It’s a wonderfully nourishing and effective way to get your skin clean before bed..
Key Ingredients:
- Coconut Oil
Benefits:
- Melts All Makeup
- Conditions Lashes
- Nourishing
- All-Natural
Pro Tip: Use a pea-sized amount on your fingertips and gently massage over closed eyes before wiping away with a soft cloth.
Get the Recipe: Pure Coconut Oil for Effortless Makeup Removal