31 Natural Eye Makeup Remover Recipes

Removing makeup gently and naturally is key to healthy, glowing skin.

Ditching harsh chemicals for simple, effective DIY solutions means you can pamper your skin while keeping it clear and refreshed.

These homemade recipes are designed to be kind to your skin, especially the delicate eye area, and use nourishing ingredients you might already have at home.

Table of Contents

1. Gentle Eye Makeup Remover with Baby Oil and Baby Shampoo

This super simple eye makeup remover is a breeze to make and remarkably effective, even for waterproof mascara.

It combines baby oil and tear-free baby shampoo with water to gently lift away all traces of makeup.

It’s a fantastic budget-friendly option that feels luxuriously gentle on your delicate eye area.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Effectively removes makeup
Gentle on eyes
Cost-effective

Pro Tip: Shake the mixture well before each use to ensure the ingredients are fully combined.

Get the Recipe: Gentle Eye Makeup Remover with Baby Oil and Baby Shampoo

2. Soothing Makeup Remover Pads with Rose Water and Jojoba Oil

These makeup remover pads are a dream for sensitive skin, offering a refreshing and soothing way to remove makeup.

They combine the calming properties of rose water with the moisturizing benefits of jojoba oil, creating a gentle yet effective cleanser.

You can easily make them at home and store them in a jar for quick and easy makeup removal.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Soothes and tones skin
Moisturizes gently
Removes tough makeup

Pro Tip: For an extra cooling effect, store your prepared pads in the refrigerator.

Get the Recipe: Soothing Makeup Remover Pads with Rose Water and Jojoba Oil

3. Nourishing Makeup Remover with Coconut Oil and Tea Tree Oil

This homemade makeup remover harnesses the power of coconut oil to deeply moisturize and gently lift away makeup, even stubborn waterproof formulas.

Tea tree oil adds its antibacterial properties, making it a great option for keeping skin clear.

It leaves your skin feeling soft, smooth, and nourished.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Deeply moisturizing
Antibacterial properties
Helps with acne

Pro Tip: Coconut oil can be great for the eye area, but if you’re prone to breakouts, it’s best to keep it confined to just the eyes.

Get the Recipe: Nourishing Makeup Remover with Coconut Oil and Tea Tree Oil

4. Refreshing Micellar Makeup Remover Wipes

These DIY makeup remover wipes offer an eco-friendly and incredibly convenient way to cleanse your skin.

They’re infused with a gentle micellar formula featuring rose water and glycerin, which effortlessly melts away makeup while leaving your skin soothed and moisturized.

You can use compostable wipes or reusable cloths for a truly sustainable option.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Effortlessly removes makeup
Soothes and moisturizes
Eco-friendly

Pro Tip: For travel, keep a few of these wipes in a sterilized, resealable silicone bag.

Get the Recipe: Refreshing Micellar Makeup Remover Wipes

5. Creamy Natural Makeup Remover with Coconut Oil and Glycerin

This luxurious homemade makeup remover uses a simple cream base blended with fractionated coconut oil and vegetable glycerin.

It’s incredibly gentle and effectively removes makeup without stripping your skin’s natural moisture.

The result is soft, hydrated, and clean skin, making it a must-try for a natural beauty routine.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Deeply hydrating
Gentle cleansing
Soothing for skin

Pro Tip: You can add a tiny bit of mica powder dissolved in sweet almond oil for a touch of color, if desired.

Get the Recipe: Creamy Natural Makeup Remover with Coconut Oil and Glycerin

6. Gentle Eye Makeup Remover with Coconut Oil and Lavender

This DIY eye makeup remover is a dream for sensitive skin! It gently lifts away even stubborn mascara with the nourishing power of coconut oil, which also conditions your lashes.

The addition of calming lavender essential oil adds a lovely scent and is thought to promote healthier lash growth.

It’s a super simple, budget-friendly way to remove eye makeup without irritation, leaving your skin feeling soft and your lashes looking their best.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Gentle Makeup Removal
Nourishes Eyelashes
Soothing and Calming

Pro Tip: To help the remover work even better on waterproof mascara, press a soaked cotton pad gently onto your closed eyelid for about 10 seconds before wiping.

Get the Recipe: Gentle Eye Makeup Remover with Coconut Oil and Lavender

7. Nourishing Makeup Remover Wipes with Coconut Oil and Castile Soap

These DIY makeup remover wipes are a fantastic, toxin-free alternative to store-bought options.

They combine the moisturizing benefits of fractionated coconut oil to dissolve makeup with the cleansing power of Dr.

Bronner’s gentle castile soap.

Your skin will feel clean and soft, not dry or stripped, after using them.

They’re perfect for a quick swipe to remove foundation and eye makeup, leaving your complexion feeling refreshed.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Cleanses Without Stripping
Dissolves Makeup and Dirt
Moisturizing

Pro Tip: After using the wipe to remove makeup, hold a warm washcloth over your face for a minute to soften and hydrate your skin even further.

Get the Recipe: Nourishing Makeup Remover Wipes with Coconut Oil and Castile Soap

8. Simple Witch Hazel and Almond Oil Makeup Remover

This incredibly simple DIY makeup remover uses just two powerhouse ingredients: witch hazel and sweet almond oil.

Witch hazel acts as a gentle astringent to cleanse and refresh, while sweet almond oil deeply nourishes and moisturizes the delicate skin around your eyes.

It’s an effective way to melt away makeup, even stubborn mascara, without harsh chemicals, leaving your skin feeling soft and cared for.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Gentle Cleansing
Soothes and Balances Skin
Nourishing and Moisturizing

Pro Tip: If you’re having trouble with waterproof mascara, let the saturated cotton pad sit on your closed eye for about 15 seconds to allow the oils to break down the makeup before wiping.

Get the Recipe: Simple Witch Hazel and Almond Oil Makeup Remover

9. Two-Ingredient Witch Hazel and Almond Oil Eye Makeup Remover

This DIY makeup remover is wonderfully effective and incredibly easy to whip up! Combining witch hazel for its gentle astringent and cleansing properties with nourishing sweet almond oil for its moisturizing benefits, this recipe is perfect for the delicate eye area.

It dissolves makeup beautifully, leaving your skin feeling clean, soft, and refreshed without any irritation.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Dissolves Makeup Effectively
Nourishes Delicate Skin
Gentle and Refreshing

Pro Tip: Store your homemade remover in a dark glass bottle to protect the oils from light and prolong its freshness. Give it a gentle shake before each use.

Get the Recipe: Two-Ingredient Witch Hazel and Almond Oil Eye Makeup Remover

10. Luxurious DIY Cleansing Balm with Shea Butter and Coconut Oil

Indulge your skin with this luxurious DIY cleansing balm! Made with just two natural ingredients, unrefined shea butter and virgin coconut oil, it melts away even the thickest makeup, leaving your skin incredibly clean, soft, and moisturized.

This balm feels wonderfully rich and nourishing, providing a pampering experience while effectively cleansing without stripping your skin’s natural protective barrier.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Melts Away Makeup
Deeply Cleanses
Leaves Skin Soft and Moisturized

Pro Tip: To customize the scent, you can add a few drops of skin-safe essential oils, but always be cautious and do a patch test first.

Get the Recipe: Luxurious DIY Cleansing Balm with Shea Butter and Coconut Oil

11. Natural Makeup Remover with Witch Hazel and Jojoba Oil

This recipe offers a simple yet effective natural makeup remover using witch hazel and jojoba oil.

Jojoba oil is fantastic because it closely mimics your skin’s natural sebum, making it great for all skin types, while witch hazel acts as a gentle toner.

Together, they cleanse and condition your skin, leaving it feeling refreshed and balanced without any greasiness.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Gentle Cleansing
Balances Skin
Moisturizing

Pro Tip: Be cautious when using witch hazel around the eyes; ensure your eyes are closed while wiping the area.

Get the Recipe: Natural Makeup Remover with Witch Hazel and Jojoba Oil

12. Easy Natural Makeup Remover with Jojoba, Witch Hazel, and Water

This DIY natural makeup remover is a breeze to make, combining jojoba oil for its amazing skin-mimicking properties, witch hazel for toning, and filtered water to dilute.

It’s designed to be gentle and effective, effortlessly dissolving makeup while leaving your skin feeling hydrated and clean.

A simple shake before use ensures the ingredients are well-mixed for a refreshing cleansing experience.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Effectively Removes Makeup
Hydrates Skin
Suitable for Most Skin Types

Pro Tip: Always perform a patch test on a small area of skin before using any new DIY product to ensure you don’t have any adverse reactions.

Get the Recipe: Easy Natural Makeup Remover with Jojoba, Witch Hazel, and Water

13. Emulsifying Cleansing Balm with Mango Butter and MCT Coconut Oil

This luxurious cleansing balm melts away makeup, even stubborn waterproof types, while leaving your skin feeling deeply moisturized.

It’s a fantastic multi-tasker that cleanses, removes debris, and nourishes all in one step, making your skincare routine beautifully simple.

The blend of mango butter and MCT coconut oil creates a silky texture that’s a delight to use.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Effective Makeup Removal
Deep Moisturization
Skin Nourishment

Pro Tip: For an extra skin-loving boost, consider adding a drop of Vitamin E oil for its antioxidant properties.

Get the Recipe: Emulsifying Cleansing Balm with Mango Butter and MCT Coconut Oil

14. Natural Eye Makeup Remover with Olive Oil and Aloe Vera

Gently lift away eye makeup with this simple, all-natural recipe.

It’s a wonderfully effective way to remove even waterproof mascara and eyeliner without any harsh rubbing.

The blend of olive oil and aloe vera gel is soothing for the delicate eye area, leaving it feeling soft and hydrated, not stripped.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Gentle Makeup Removal
Soothes Delicate Skin
Hydrating

Pro Tip: You can substitute grapeseed oil for olive oil if you prefer a lighter feel.

Get the Recipe: Natural Eye Makeup Remover with Olive Oil and Aloe Vera

15. Gentle Makeup Remover Wipes with Grapeseed Oil and Lavender

Create your own refreshing makeup remover wipes that are incredibly easy to make and use.

These wipes effortlessly dissolve makeup while witch hazel helps to cleanse and soothe your skin.

A touch of lavender essential oil adds a lovely scent and calming benefits, making your makeup removal routine a spa-like experience.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Removes Makeup and Dirt
Soothes Skin
Pleasant Aroma

Pro Tip: If you have sensitive skin or plan to use these around your eyes, consider omitting the essential oils.

Get the Recipe: Gentle Makeup Remover Wipes with Grapeseed Oil and Lavender

16. Nourishing Makeup Removing Oil with Carrier Oils and Vitamin E

This rich makeup removing oil is perfect for dissolving all traces of makeup while deeply moisturizing your skin.

It leaves your skin feeling incredibly soft and nourished, making it a wonderful treat, especially for dry skin.

You can even use it all over your body for an extra dose of hydration.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Dissolves Makeup
Deep Moisturization
Softens Skin

Pro Tip: Shake well before each use to ensure all the oils are perfectly blended.

Get the Recipe: Nourishing Makeup Removing Oil with Carrier Oils and Vitamin E

17. Hydrating Coconut Oil Makeup Remover Wipes

Say goodbye to dry, irritated skin caused by harsh makeup removers! These delightful DIY wipes, featuring fractionated coconut oil and aloe vera gel, gently lift away makeup while providing essential moisture.

Your skin will feel wonderfully smooth and soft after every use, making this a must-try for a gentle clean.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Gentle and Moisturizing
Alcohol-Free
Soothing

Pro Tip: For a completely waste-free option, use reusable cotton or bamboo pads and store the solution in a separate bottle.

Get the Recipe: Hydrating Coconut Oil Makeup Remover Wipes

18. Natural Makeup Remover with Olive Oil & Witch Hazel

This easy DIY makeup remover is a dream for effortlessly sweeping away makeup, even the waterproof kind! It combines the gentle cleansing power of witch hazel with the nourishing properties of olive oil, leaving your skin feeling soft and smooth, never stripped or dry.

It’s a simple, effective, and natural solution for clean skin.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Removes all makeup, including waterproof
Leaves skin feeling smooth
Gentle and natural

Pro Tip: Give the bottle a good shake before each use, as the oil and water will naturally separate.

Get the Recipe: Natural Makeup Remover with Olive Oil & Witch Hazel

19. Gentle Eye Makeup Remover with Grapeseed Oil and Witch Hazel

This DIY makeup remover is a game-changer for gently and thoroughly removing even stubborn eye makeup.

It features grapeseed oil, known for its lightness, and witch hazel, which has cleansing and balancing properties.

Your skin will feel soft and refreshed, making makeup removal a breeze without irritation.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Gentle on sensitive skin and eyes
Thoroughly removes makeup
Leaves skin soft and moisturized

Pro Tip: You can add a touch of Vitamin E oil to help prolong shelf life and boost its nourishing qualities.

Get the Recipe: Gentle Eye Makeup Remover with Grapeseed Oil and Witch Hazel

20. Nourishing DIY Makeup Remover Cream

Experience a rich and creamy way to melt away makeup, even stubborn waterproof formulas! This DIY cream is packed with skin-loving ingredients that gently hydrate and protect your skin barrier.

It’s perfect for all skin types and leaves your complexion feeling soft and cared for after every use.

Benefits:

Melts away makeup, including waterproof
Hydrates and protects skin
Suitable for all skin types

Pro Tip: Customize this cream with essential oils suited to your skin type for added benefits.

Get the Recipe: Nourishing DIY Makeup Remover Cream

21. Baby Shampoo Eye Makeup Remover Hack

For a quick and surprisingly effective way to tackle tough eye makeup, try this simple hack! Using a tiny amount of no-tears baby shampoo on a Q-tip gently lifts away mascara and liner.

It’s a budget-friendly and fast solution when you need makeup gone in a flash, leaving your eyes feeling clean.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Effectively removes waterproof eye makeup
Cost-effective and quick
Gentle for the eye area

Pro Tip: Follow up with a clean, damp cloth and a rinse of lukewarm water to ensure all residue is removed.

Get the Recipe: Baby Shampoo Eye Makeup Remover Hack

22. Effective Olive Oil Eye Makeup Remover

Discover the power of olive oil for makeup removal! This readily available ingredient is a safe, inexpensive, and effective way to dissolve eye makeup, including stubborn mascara.

Its natural moisturizing properties leave your skin feeling soft and nourished, making it a wonderful choice for your nightly routine.

Key Ingredients:

Olive Oil

Benefits:

Safe, inexpensive, and effective
Moisturizing and anti-aging properties
Removes all types of eye makeup

Pro Tip: Extra virgin olive oil is best for skincare due to its higher concentration of beneficial compounds.

Get the Recipe: Effective Olive Oil Eye Makeup Remover

23. DIY Eye Makeup Remover Pads with Jojoba Oil and Witch Hazel

Create your own convenient makeup remover pads that are gentle on your eyes and skin! This recipe uses jojoba oil for its mildness and witch hazel for effective cleansing.

They’re perfect for leaving your lashes and eyelids feeling clean, soft, and nourished, all while being an eco-friendly alternative to disposable wipes.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Soft and gentle on sensitive skin
Zero waste option
Saves money

Pro Tip: Add a drop of lavender essential oil for its soothing properties and potential lash-strengthening benefits.

Get the Recipe: DIY Eye Makeup Remover Pads with Jojoba Oil and Witch Hazel

24. Gentle Micellar Water Makeup Remover

This easy-to-make micellar water is a wonderfully gentle way to cleanse your skin and remove makeup.

It uses simple ingredients like purified water, witch hazel, and glycerin to lift away impurities without any harsh scrubbing.

It’s a lightweight, no-rinse option that leaves your skin feeling clean and refreshed, making it a perfect first step in your nightly routine.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Gentle cleansing
Removes makeup and residue
Lightweight feel
No rinsing required

Pro Tip: Shake gently before each use, as the ingredients can naturally separate over time.

Get the Recipe: Gentle Micellar Water Makeup Remover

25. Olive Oil and Witch Hazel Eye Makeup Remover

This straightforward recipe combines the makeup-melting power of olive oil with the cleansing properties of witch hazel.

It’s a simple, effective way to dissolve eye makeup, including stubborn mascara, without causing irritation.

You’ll love how soft and clean your skin feels afterwards, making it a must-try for anyone seeking a natural eye makeup remover.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Dissolves eye makeup
Gentle on the eyes
Simple ingredients

Pro Tip: You can adjust the ratio of olive oil to witch hazel to suit your preference for more or less moisturizing.

Get the Recipe: Olive Oil and Witch Hazel Eye Makeup Remover

26. Nourishing Coconut Oil and Castile Soap Makeup Remover Wipes

Create your own convenient and eco-friendly makeup remover wipes with this nourishing recipe.

It uses fractionated coconut oil to gently lift away makeup, combined with gentle castile soap and witch hazel to cleanse and tone.

These wipes are a budget-friendly and kinder alternative to disposable ones, leaving your skin feeling soft and cared for.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Effectively removes makeup
Gentle on skin
Cost-effective

Pro Tip: For a zero-waste option, use reusable bamboo or cotton pads instead of disposable cotton rounds.

Get the Recipe: Nourishing Coconut Oil and Castile Soap Makeup Remover Wipes

27. Simple Oil-Based Makeup Remover with Grapeseed Oil

Discover the power of pure oils for makeup removal! Grapeseed oil is a fantastic choice because it’s lightweight and dissolves makeup effectively without feeling greasy.

It’s a simple, single-ingredient solution that works wonderfully for melting away stubborn makeup, leaving your skin clean and balanced.

Key Ingredients:

Grapeseed oil

Benefits:

Melts away makeup
Lightweight feel
Minimally comedogenic

Pro Tip: If you have acne-prone skin, always check the comedogenic rating of any oil you choose to ensure it won’t clog your pores.

Get the Recipe: Simple Oil-Based Makeup Remover with Grapeseed Oil

28. Gentle Cleansing Makeup Remover with Castile Soap and Coconut Oil

This all-natural makeup remover offers a gentle yet effective way to cleanse your face and lashes.

It combines the cleansing power of castile soap with the nourishing moisture of fractionated coconut oil and a hint of vitamin E.

It’s a fantastic choice to remove everything from mascara to foundation without over-drying or irritating your skin, leaving it naturally glowing.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Cleanses and moisturizes
Removes tough makeup
Non-stripping formula

Pro Tip: You can store this liquid in a squeeze bottle or pour it over reusable cotton rounds for easy use.

Get the Recipe: Gentle Cleansing Makeup Remover with Castile Soap and Coconut Oil

29. Soothing Eye Makeup Remover with Witch Hazel, Aloe Vera, and Olive Oil

This refreshing eye makeup remover is a delightful blend designed to be gentle on your skin while being tough on makeup.

It combines the natural astringent properties of witch hazel with the soothing touch of aloe vera gel and the makeup-melting power of olive oil.

This balanced formula cleanses without leaving a greasy feel, leaving your delicate eye area feeling calm, clean, and wonderfully refreshed.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Light and non-greasy
Soothing and calming
Effective makeup removal

Pro Tip: Give the bottle a good shake before each use, as the oil and witch hazel can naturally separate.

Get the Recipe: Soothing Eye Makeup Remover with Witch Hazel, Aloe Vera, and Olive Oil

30. Effective and Non-Stinging Eye Makeup Remover

Tired of eye makeup removers that sting or leave a greasy residue? This DIY recipe is a winner! It effectively removes even waterproof mascara with ease, thanks to a smart combination of ingredients that balance the power of oils with elements that make them easier to remove.

You get clean skin without irritation, and it’s incredibly budget-friendly.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Removes waterproof mascara
No stinging
Cost-effective

Pro Tip: Using olive oil from a trusted source can be a very cost-effective option for this recipe.

Get the Recipe: Effective and Non-Stinging Eye Makeup Remover

31. Customizable Makeup Remover with Coconut Oil, Olive Oil, and Witch Hazel

This versatile set of recipes allows you to tailor your makeup remover to your specific skin needs.

Whether you prefer the rich hydration of coconut oil for dry skin, the balancing act of witch hazel for oily skin, or the gentle touch of aloe vera for sensitive skin, these options are effective and natural.

They’re a fantastic, cost-effective way to keep your skin clean and happy.

Key Ingredients:

Benefits:

Suitable for all skin types
Natural ingredients
Customizable formulas

Pro Tip: Always perform a patch test on a small area of your skin before using any new homemade product.

Get the Recipe: Customizable Makeup Remover with Coconut Oil, Olive Oil, and Witch Hazel